| ||||
|
Ordinary People Baran (directed by Majid Majidi) Runaway (directed by Kim Longinotto and Ziba Mir-Hosseini) Reviewed by Mike Hertenstein
One of the big names in this film renaissance is director Majid
Majidi, whose previous two films have enjoyed the highest
visibility of Iranian movies in North American distribution. If
you haven't seen the marvelous Children of Heaven, or the
gorgeous Color of Paradise, head on down to your local
Blockbuster, where sometime next year you'll also be able to rent
Majidi's newest portrait of ordinary Iranian life,
Baran.
Of course, "ordinary" is a matter of style and approach, for the
setting of Baran involves the ongoing disruption of
ordinary Iranian life by the presence of a million and a half
Afghan refugees -- which makes this film relevant to American
viewers in ways unforseen when the film was booked for the festival.
Victims of their own nation's never ending wars, the Afghans in
this film aren't merely pawns of a politicized story, but rather
ordinary people themselves, trying to feed their families, or
raising money to either send back home or go home themselves.
The setting is a high-rise construction site, where illegal
Afghan workers scatter whenever building inspectors show up to
warn the owner of the consequences for hiring illegal workers.
One worker, Lateef, is -- to use an American designation for a
universal position -- the low man on the totem pole. His job is
hauling cement, and making hot tea to bring to his fellow workers
(a delightfully civilized Iranian custom we could learn from).
Lateef is an obnoxious trickster, also a universal type, who
thinks both that the world owes him a living, and that the world
is out to get him. Such an attitude costs him his job, which he
loses to a young Afghani worker who seems at first even more
useless. But industrious young Rahmat proves a worth that
transforms the task of perfunctorily dispensing "dishwater" tea
into an art form, bringing hominess and humanity to the rough
surroundings -- and, ultimately and especially, to Lateef.
Majidi continues to direct with solid Fordian competence, but
without the mythic sensibilities: his framing, scene building,
and storytelling are dependable and true -- though his filmmaking
style is not quite as plainspoken as the stories. Indeed,
cinematograpaher Mohammed Davudu once again lights and composes
with a matching confidence, one beautiful image after another.
Ultimately, a core of humanity and common decency is the
trademark of Majidi's work. The message here would seem to be:
if you treat people as decent human beings, they will become
decent human beings. And while the film is more realistic than mythic, the
underlying thrust seems at some level allegorical: subtle messages that may
one day prove revolutionary indeed in Iran.
That film's award-winning directors are back with Runaway,
where the camera is set up in a women's shelter in Tehran.
As in the earlier film, viewers are given an astonishing and
intimate look at family problem-solving under an Islamic regime.
Instead of a male judge, the professional functionary here is a
female counselor. And unlike the stereotype of an Islamic woman,
this counselor is educated, sensible and clearly in charge. The
film revolves around her intake desk, where she meets girls and
discusses with them the problems that brought them to the
shelter, which she then tries to help solve and send them
home.
The problems seem no different than what you'd hear about if the
camera had been set up at the Department of Human Services in my
Chicago neighborhood: the usual family dysfunctions and
conflicts, over grades, boundaries, stories of physical and
sexual abuse, drugs, communication breakdown, divorce.
In addition to scenes in the counselor's office, the documentary
follows several girls through the entire process of coming in,
working through their problems, and moving on to -- hopefully --
a better situation, either back home or out on their own. The
relationships that develop among the girls are sweet and
powerful, as they learn to support one another through hard
times.
I found it nearly impossible to watch the earlier documentary at
the divorce court without being constantly distracted by my
indignation at a patriarchical system that so patently, absurdly
-- to my non-Islamic frame of reference -- denies women basic
civil rights, even an official voice in determining their own
fate. (And what made Divorce, Iranian Style a delight was
the ways women made their voices heard in unofficial ways.)
In Runaway, however, we see women in charge for much of
the film, and one can sometimes forget about the system under
which they live and get caught up in the universality of their
problems and problem-solving. One almost gets a sense that
sensible, educated women actually run the country.
Sadly, this is far from the case.
For the men do make their appearance felt: first, by showing up,
to collect daughters and sisters and try to talk them into coming
home. This is where the sense of indignation rises in this film.
For none of the men seem to have any interest in taking seriously
the problems that brought the girls to the shelter. Over and
over again, one hears from the male family heads concern that the
girls, in their one or two nights on the street between home and
shelter, lost their virginity: the concern is that they are still
"intact". And, most infuriatingly, the concern has nothing to do
with the girls themselves, and everything to do with family
"honor".
We also hear discussion of the Police Unit for Combatting Social
Corruption. Of arranged marriages between grown men and twelve
year olds. We see a girl who has fled a step-father she accuses
of trying to rape her talked into admitting it was her fault. We
see another girl, who had been catcalled in the street, blamed
for that incident because, her family insists, she walked
"improperly". "All men are wolves," it is noted by men, more
than once: and it's easy to agree with them. It's also easy to
see how this attitude leads from moderate Fundamentalist Islam to
a Taliban with its head-to-toe garments to protect men from their
lust. The real crime is that the wrong people are punished.
Despite the reminder of the oppressiveness of the regime, there
is so much in Runaway that gives me hope, not least the
fact that it was made in the first place and shown in America.
The other thing that gives me hope is the common sense of the
Iranian women, who clearly won't put up with this stuff
forever.
|
..........................more: 37th Chicago International Film Festival, Oct. 4-18, 2001 Revolutionary Cinema of Iran: Iranian Filmmakers Continue to Test Boundaries and Upset Expectations Movies Iranian Style: A Survey of Films & Directors Featured Iranian Films at Flickerings 2002 (Kandahar, The Circle, Close-Up, Leila, Hamoun, Color of Paradise)
| |||
|
| ||||