Mysterious Island
(1951)
Directed by Spencer Gordon Bennet
Richard Crane (Captain Cyrus Harding), Marshall Reed (Jack Pencroft), Herbert
Brown (Hugh Prosser), Gideon Spillett (Bernie Hamilton), Rulu of Mercury
(Karen Randle), Leonard Penn (Captain Nemo)
The sole Jules Verne film made in America
during that long drought was one of those cheap, juvenile serials I mentioned:
1951’s Mysterious Island from Columbia Pictures. Like most Columbia
serials, this one is slow, plot-heavy, creaky, and rambling. Nevertheless, it
does boast the distinction of being the most faithful adaptation of Verne’s
original book on film (and there are at least four other existing versions!).
L’Île mystérieuse is basically a straightforward
survival story along the lines of Swiss Family Robinson; it has no gill men
or giant octopi, no prehistoric birds or nautiloid cephalopods. And to be honest,
it doesn’t have any visitors from Mercury, either—a wacky element
that even this “faithful” version tosses into the mix at one point.
Still, Verne’s actual plot really is enacted here, point by laborious
point, so I suppose the filmmakers deserve at least a little credit for authenticity.
Fans of Fifties TV will recognize leading man Richard Crane as none other than
Rocky Jones—Space Ranger himself; and Captain Nemo is portrayed in this
version by Leonard Penn, another Rocky Jones alum. Pirate captain Gene Roth
should be another familiar face to genre buffs, having appeared in films like
Earth vs. the Spider and George Pal’s Atlantis: The Lost Continent.
Other than these nostalgic pleasures, the Mysterious Island serial
has little to offer. Those who do make the attempt are likely to find themselves
giving up after a chapter or two and going back instead to Harryhausen’s
1961 classic, despite its many liberties with the text.
<<< Previous |
Fireside SF Home |
Next >>>
|